Egg Harbor Cafe

This was my first visit to this restaurant during a trip to Atlanta on 1/1/26. We were seated right away. Ambience was nice. Kevin, our sever, was knowledgeable, prompt, pleasant and attentive. Menu listed many tantalizing items. Kids menu had many selections. Orders were scrambled eggs with great variety of addons, egg Benedict, cinnamon French toast, berry covered French toast, and kids waffles. Food arrived quickly and hot. Everyone in the party gave an A grade and recommended another visit upon our return to Atlanta.

Egg Harbor Cafe was wonderful! I had French toast and an iced coffee, both were delicious. We had a party of over 10, and they easily accommodated us in the patio area, which was nice and warm on a chilly day. Everyone was welcoming, and we all really enjoyed our time there. Highly recommend!

From entering and exiting all staff was kind and attentive. Our server Olga was the best. The food was plentiful and good. The specialty hot chocolate was a nice touch for the season and oh so good.

The only positive thing I can honestly say about Egg Harbor is that it’s close to our home. Unfortunately, everything else about our visit fell short. The prices are extremely high for the quantity and quality of the food we received, which made the entire meal feel like a poor value from the start. I mean $5 a piece for a cup of subpar coffee… On top of that, the service was disappointing. Our server wasn’t clear on the menu items, and we didn’t get any explanation until after our meals were already on the table. Only then did she mention, “Oh, we’ve recently had a menu change—some portions may look smaller and some may look bigger.” This is the kind of thing that should be communicated upfront, not after customers have already committed to their order. Overall, the experience felt rush

Our experience was great, the food was delicious and I really enjoyed the jam. One of our party members eggs came out undercooked and the server kindly replaced them for us and brought a new English muffin since the eggs had touched the other one. 10/10 everything was delicious, the lobster scramble is amazing!