Edgartown Seafood Market

we ordered two two pound lobsters cooked and cracked as done many times over 35 years. we got them home and weighed them - see photos attached of digital scale. they were 1 pound one ounce each. the next day we went in to discuss this and brought photos of each lobster on he digital scale and andy was rude and sarcastic. he claimed they lost weight when cracked. really? half their weight? after some time he offered to refund half the price, but it was really his rudeness that prompts this review. no matter what I said he kept saying sarcastically over and over 'I hope you enjoyed your two pound lobsters' Even though they were half of that. We really never expected this kind of attitude on mv in this day and age. They screwed up, why not admit it, apologize and move on?

A gem in Edgartown. The guys are super nice, the seafood is super fresh and the hot buttered lobster roll is simply the best. Had one for the first time today. Will definitely be back. Highly recommend.

The people who work here were so kind!! The lobster roll was also delicious, maybe needs a little more salt. Would recommend overall!

Best lobster roll and clam chowder I've had on the island! A must-go.

These guys rule. Best lobster, sole and swordfish. They are so kind and hospitable. What a gem of a store. See you again soon, I sure hope! Thank you.