Crestwood Pizza

Meatballs & Sauce 😋 delicious. Nice welcoming front staff - 'Sauce Boss' John 👌 makes a Fabulous Penne alla Vodka - Chicken / Veal dishes. Very good, tasty 🍕 Pizza Pie - standard italian pizzaria menu - Excellent!

Right across from the Crestwood train station, this family-run pizzeria is as local as it gets. In a town with deep Italian roots, Crestwood Pizza is the kind of spot where everyone on the street is carrying their pizza boxes, and the owners know half the customers by name. Inside, it’s organized chaos—the kind only a busy, well-loved pizza place can have. The staff move like fighting a war (because they are), yet still calm as just another regular day for them. Despite the rush, they’re friendly, efficient, and warm. The pizzas are classic New York style or Sicilian style. The single slices are pre-made and warmed up, but still come out tasting great. Fair prices, generous portions, and an atmosphere full of neighborhood charm make this a spot I’ll keep coming back to. Whether you’re ho

Absolutely fantastic experience! The staff was incredibly patient with our indecisiveness and provided top-notch customer service. This spot is perfect for families, and the pizza is everything you’d want from a classic New York slice—crispy crust, gooey cheese, and just the right amount of pepperoni. Plus, the location is super convenient, right next to Crestwood Station! If you’re looking for a place with great food and friendly, personable service, this is definitely the spot to be. Highly recommend!

Just wanted to share that today, 2/7/26, my 15 yo son went into this pizzeria while airing for me to pick him up- we live 10 minutes away. Tried to buy a soda but his debit card would not work for some reason. The employee a Male Hispanic threw him out because he didn’t buy anything and made him wait outside in feels like -14 weather til I got there. Btw the place was empty when I got there. I understand that you may not want kids hanging around if they are not purchasing but on a cold day like today he could have let him wait there the less than 10 minutes it took me to get there.My son and I have been there a few times in the past food is nothing to rave about and I used to be in the Pizza business for many years. I hope nobody thinks this is a nice family place because it’s obviously

Great pizza and fantastic rolls. Very delicious cheese pizza. Reasonable prices. Conveniently across from Crestwood MetroNorth station. Metered street parking. Cash and credit are both accepted. Dine in available. 11/2022