Costa's Restaurant & Pizzeria

I've never had problems with this pizzeria; in fact, it was one of my favorites, until today. Everything was fine, but when I received the pizza, it was very disappointing. The crusts were very thin. They put sauce on the Hawaiian pizza, and that's why we ordered from there because they never put sauce on theirs. The pineapple sauce was very poor, but the worst part is that they are extremely thin. I'm sorry, but I will stop ordering from there.

We just had my daughters baby shower here and I don't have enough good things to say about the venue! From beginning to end, they worked with my daughters in the planning, execution and pricing. First, the food was excellent, there was so much of everything. All the dishes were delicious! The antipasto had so many choices, there was a large variety of cheeses to choose from and the salad was excellent. The pastas were all cooked to perfection and the gravy 😘!‹ The chicken was tender and melted in your mouth. Best of all were the meatballs; they're huge and delicious!! They also provided the cake which was yummy! The server was amazing. She was right there to help the guests, keep the tables clean, drinks refreshed and made sure we had what we needed for the 2 babies at the party and she

After living in town for years, we decided to order pizza from this place for the first time, and it was definitely an "experience". We ordered via the website, and the first thing we noticed was that there is ZERO description on the menu regarding what is on each pizza, so we hoped for the best as they are well known in the community. We placed an order for a Basil pizza and a Hawaiian, nothing extra, no notes nor dietary restrictions. 5 mins later, we received a call from the restaurant. Without skipping a beat, she employee exploded at us for constantly adding the "deluxe pizza" to our order and confuses their staff, accusing us of constantly making this mistake on our order which I had to remind her, after waiting for her finish talking to a customer like her child, that this is the fi

I booked Costa’s for my sister’s engagement party on 11/30/24, and we chose the room in the back. It had beautiful string lights hanging from the ceiling, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. We worked with Brian, and he was absolutely amazing! His patience and great personality made the entire process so enjoyable. The food was surprisingly tasty and very affordable! Brian even allowed us to decorate the night before, which was such a nice touch. If you’re looking for fantastic staff and affordable prices, I highly recommend booking Costa’s!

This might be some of the best Italian food that I’ve had in NJ yet. We stumbled upon this place by accident, and it was such a pleasant surprise! We got the penne vodka and shrimp scampi - both were amazing but the scampi was to die for! Even the bread was good. On top of all that, the service was absolutely amazing - Brian is so kind and attentive. We will be back, probably with the whole family!