Cold Stone Creamery

When decided to come here, be sure to disregard the overall low rating- all previous 1 star reviews complain about how the business has not opened. This is a wonderful Cold Stone, and I'm very happy that Sun Prairie has it! It's a shame we're later on in the season, making ice cream adventures more scarce, but this will definitely be my go-to for ice cream in Sun Prairie! Prices are reasonable, quality is top notch, just as you'd expect at other locations. I wish the team here the absolute best, and I'll be back!

Cold Stone finally opened! The store looks amazing, and the employees are welcoming, friendly, and very helpful. The ice cream is absolutely delicious, and the waffle cone is fresh and so good! A wonderful experience overall, and I’m really happy to finally have one so close to home. Wishing the Cold Stone team lots of success!

Im happy that cold stone is open. Great service and the owner is really nice. Go check them out, even though its super cold outside. Also love the murals on the windows.

Coldstone catered our banquet and we had an amazing array of ice cream cupcakes that were beautifully customized and decorated to go with our West Wolves spirit! Fully enjoyed by our athletes and their families. Would ABSOLUTELY recommend this!

Busy night. Line of about 10 people. Workers were talking to each other more than paying attention to their customers. 2 owners in the back and not jumping out to help them. They seemed to be arguing. Not a good look. Ice cream was way too soft (may need to blast freeze it longer). The dark chocolate seemed sour. Our first time in. Was excited as I used to own one years ago. No one sang, greeted us nicely… big disappointment overall. Will stick to going to Fitchburg. Bummer.