Ciro's Pizza

Ciro’s pizza has a great regular slice. Great sauce good cheese with the proper amount of grease. Super thin crust. I would say one of the best regular slices in the area. Place has that old school nostalgia. Don’t come here and order anything crazy Buffalo wings were very good as well super crispy. The sauce was mixed with blue cheese with a light heat. Staff is very nice and friendly. They are churning out pizza. Good job will definitely eat again Get a hot slice and a classic soda.

The dough is not up to par with good fermented dough at other pizza restaurants. Looks better than is tastes.

Went for lunch with family was nice clean spacious spot. Had a pepperoni 🍕 slice and a pepperoni pin wheel with sauce was really good. Wings were different wasn’t my fave but the pie was great!

Found this place on Reddit as the go-to spot while staying in Commack. I must confirm that this pizza is legit! I ordered 2 slices with 4 toppings each, one grandma slice and a pepperoni roll ($22 and change-not bad). Everything was delicious, but the grandma slice was extra special even though it was just plain cheese. Didn’t make it to the picture but trust me and the other reviews-you’ll want at least a slice of grandma with whatever you order. And, nobody can accuse this place of skimping on the toppings (see picture) Wow! Simply delicious and the service was friendly even with my slightly custom order.

Best pizza in Smithtown hands down. Also the wings are a must try. They mix the blue cheese with the buffalo which makes it elite. It terms of the pizza, Sauce to cheese ratio is very good. You can tell high quality ingredients are used. Crust is a little on the thick side but the taste of the sauce outweighs that.