Chatterbox Pleasantville

This place needs 10 stars - the food was absolutely amazing. I ordered the lobster ravioli and a cosmo for my beverage. The other people in my party got the escarole and a pizza, which they both really enjoyed. We went for the Super Bowl and had a great time. Our server was friendly, and everything came out in a timely manner. 10/10!

My girlfriend was dining here recently and during the clearing of the salad course, there was an accidental spill of oil that unfortunately went all over her jacket. Accidents happen, and that part was completely understood. I do want to specifically call out the waiter, who was absolutely amazing. He immediately came over with napkins and dish soap and did everything he could to help clean it and make the situation better. His response and attitude were truly appreciated. The only disappointment that evening was the lack of acknowledgment from manager at the time. He manager did not come to the table, and the only offer relayed was a cup of coffee — no apology or check-in, which felt a bit dismissive in the moment. That said, I came back the following evening and spoke directly with th

Food was phenomenal! I was there on a Saturday night, so I know I'm about to sound like a grandma, but it was packed. Tables are very close together, and I felt a little like a sardine. That being said, I will definitely be back. The food and service were awesome. Don't take my comments negatively about the crowds. Just keep in mind that if you want a quiet spot to chat and eat, this may not be the best choice on a Saturday. If you're looking for a lively party scene for dinner, then this is the spot for you 100%.

The food was superb and a fantastic addition to the pleasantville Italian selection available. Hands down some of the besy Italian we have had in some time. Restaurant was clean and tidy, and ambiance was good. We are docking 1 star because the TVs in the bar area were a bit much for our liking, and bar staff was quiet loud then again we have been there during an off hour as we were the only guests at 430.

Update 03.30.23 They clearly have a great staff because the food was just as good, if not better than last time! I posted pics of our favorites. I forgot to post a picture of the delicious Zeppolis which was a great way to end the meal. As we did last time… half of us brought food home because the portions are large enough for 2. I’m looking forward to lunch tomorrow 🤗 The karaoke continues to be good. Some of these people should definitely be hired for events they truly are that good! What a great night to go. It was Karaoke night which I’m not usually a fan of but there were people with voices that should have contracts! Staff was friendly, portions were large. Enough leftover for lunch the following day. They also have great outdoor seating and a bar that seemed pretty lovely. Gre