Arthur Avenue

A cozy little spot with a warm vibe and a wood-fired oven that makes the place smell amazing. tried the buffalo chicken pizza—it was delicious. Honestly had to stop myself from finishing the whole thing in one sitting before I get more fat.

Personal pizzas in a wood fired oven. Flavor got better as you ate it. Crust was just right. Place was rather small but the food more than made up for it.

Dined here last week. The pizzas were good, but crazily overpriced. $14 for a plain cheese pizza. That wouldn't be terrible for a normal sized personal pizza, but this one was really small, probably the equivalent pizza area of a large slice and half. I can go to a place like Mario's in Mt. Kisco, where the pizza is on the same level or better, and pay about half the price for an equivalent amount of pizza. Four of us ate cheese pizza, with a salad and some drinks for $100. I know there's inflation, but c'mon. Not a great ambiance in the place, but I could live with that if the pizza was extraordinary and reasonably priced, but that wasn't the case. The pizza was good, particularly the crust, but not in the same league as a Johnny's or many other spots in Westchester.

The Bee Sting pizza was superb. It's the closest pizza I've had outside of Rome (the rest of Italy included) that tasted like a Roman-style pizza, super thin, with minimal fire-crisped crust. Juicy. Good sauce. The cooks were polite and personal, but give you space. The pizzeria is cozy and clean. Great Italian-American ambience with Sinatra playing in the background. I look forward to returning.

If you are looking for authentic wood fire pizza, Arthur Ave is the spot! I had the pleasure of having lunch here with my CertaPro Painters team and it was one of best pizza’s I had lately. Out of the 4 pies we ordered, my favorite had to be the eggplant. Crust was baked perfectly and just the right amount of eggplant. The owners were very welcoming. Top notch service, pizza and atmosphere, you can’t go wrong. Don’t walk, run to if you are looking for delicious pizza.