Celestino's Pizza & Ristorante (New Providence)

The food was decent and better than I anticipated, but the service was disappointing. I didn’t try the pizza, so I can’t comment on that. The food could have used some garnish to make it more presentable. The dining area was loud and busy with constant takeout traffic, making it a poor choice for a quiet dinner.

Best Pizza in Town – A New Family Favorite! We tried this new pizza place and absolutely loved it! The pizza is incredibly delicious — even my three kids ate every bite and said it’s tastier than the other places we used to go. We’ll definitely be coming back again and again! On top of that, the price is unbeatable: only $12 for three huge slices. Such amazing quality at such a great value — highly recommend!

Absolutely love this place. I was a big fan of Coppolas but I am an even bigger fan of this place now and they deliver. The menu is huge and everything we have ordered has been spot on. Prices are very fair and service is extremely friendly. Highly recommend this place!

First try. There was a mixup with our takeout order. But the hospitality service to correct it and make up for it was above and beyond. Second try ordered delivery. Everything was smooth from the app to the dates to the delivery. And personable. I’m not in town. But will be a frequent customer given the excellent treatment so far. The pizzas second time around that I pictured here. Plain and southern buffalo chicken, were excellent.

Excellent food at a fair price that'll keep everyone happy! The portions are usually very generous and the quality is spot on.