Catskill Mountain Pizza Co

This place was so rude. It was almost as if it was an inconvenience us coming in not even when they were close to closing and it seemed like a burden us asking for pizza. They even said something to turn away the elderly couple in front of us. They had hours old cold pizza sitting there ready to be warmed up, not much variety of flavors. We pretty much took what was left to refuel post hike. We stayed it was to go which was true. We set the box down on one of the outside tables just to adjust ourselves and the lady at the counter sighed in frustration as if even if we changed our mind and wanted to sit eat, it would be a problem. And she said audibly in frustration "I thought they said it's to go!" This felt like the movie "get out" in this weird sundown town if you get my drift. Like men

Satisfactory pizza. A little too doughy. Something off w the oil they use. Stingy with the cheese. Being large slices doesn’t make up for lacking in other areas. Unfriendly staff. On the rude side. Made a snarky comment when I left. We heard you lady!

Bitburger on tap and excellent thin crust pizza in the oven… perfect combination after walking up Overlook Mountain in the snow and wind.

We love Catskill Mountain Pizza! The best buffalo chicken pizza and great homemade blue cheese. Service is always exceptional

Cute place on the main drag with friendly staff and a yummy pie. We had an order to go and sat outside in their seating area. It was pleasantly warm sitting in the sun as we munched. The pizza was the perfect amount of cheesy and crispy! Great lunch! Quick service and our pup liked it too!