Cataro's Italian Villa

Fantastic as always. Not only does it taste great, but it’s always perfectly assembled also! Toppings on every piece that most places struggle with.

First time here but definitely not the last! Pizza was great! It was not busy when we were there so it was very comfortable. I could imagine it gets less so, however, when they have a full house. Pleasantly surprised by alternative entrée list.

Our favorite pie in West Allis! For the piece, it’s unbeatable! We ordered a large 2 topping, appetizer, dinner salad and a bottle of wine for under $50. We will definitely be returning.

Best pizza I’ve ever had. Been coming here for 20 years and I would put this place up against any food in Wisconsin

Great food and amazing service! We had a big group of 13 people and they did a great job at serving us. The food is perfect portion sizes and the seasoning is perfect.