Castaways Steak & Seafood

We dined in one of the igloos for Valentine's Day. Food was decent. The cheesecake and mussels were amazing. Prices were high though. Staff was very nice. Overall we enjoyed ourselves.

My husband and I went here on a beautiful evening and sat outside. We had a reservation but had to wait a little longer for an outdoor seat - no problem. Our waitress, Lauren F. was the best!! She was attentive, loved every dog that walked by, and friendly. My husband and I shared a seafood chowder (chock full of seafood like lobster, bay scallops, shrimp, and fish - so, so good!) We also had the calamari (loved the sweet chili sauce). Marinara is not listed as a sauce included with the dish, but it was provided upon asking. Finally, we had the surf and turf sandwich which was mind-blowingly good. So much lobster and tender steak. The truffle fries that accompanied it were crispy and tasty!

Wonderful dinner in an atmosphere that captures the vibe of maritime Port Jefferson. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. The menu is well rounded and will accommodate most palates. The wine list and cocktails are also well thought out and cover a nice range of type and cost. Castaways also carries Guiness zero and Heineken zero, bothof which are alcohol removed beers, thank you Castaways. Ordered the Peppered Shrimp as an appetizer and it was delicious, had just the right amount of spicy flavor. Mains were chili lime grilled Salmon, fresh flavor and cooked perfectly as ordered, as well as the Fish and Chips, also really fresh flavor and perfectly cooked. If you are looking for indoor / outdoor dining with a beach atmosphere and good food, Castaways is a must try.

Great place to eat. The stuffed oysters I highly recommend. Our server was wonderful. Definitely a great spot to have lunch or dinner.

If you haven’t been here yet, I highly recommend you stop by. The owner greeted us and was genuinely interested in our satisfaction. Waitresses were really sweet. The lobster bisque and spinach and artichoke dip were everything I hoped and dreamed. Will be returning.