Casey's

I’ve eaten a lot of Casey’s pizza in my life and this one was by far the worst. Whoever was making pizzas 8/29/25 around 8pm needs to find a new line of work. I normally defend Casey’s pizza but this was definitely ‘gas station pizza’

Two stars mostly because those are harder to get taken down or it would be a one star I place breakfast pizza order yesterday evening to pick up at 6 AM as a treat for my team at work. I show up at a quarter till six to pick it up and the lights are still off. I wait until 6 o’clock no lights. Try to call the number given. When I placed my order yesterday evening, it said I could’ve placed it as early as 4 AM so if you are not in fact open, you might wanna adjust your ordering hours just in general. No answer ended up going down the road to Rhodes to throw together some similar to breakfast that I promised my coworkers I am now running late paid twice as much for breakfast and have gotten no response or answer from anyone at your store. Additionally, this is my first issue with the store.

Charged $8.00 for 2 bottled sodas, shelf was marked 2 for $5.00. Called in order for 2 large pizzas. To pick up at 7:28. At 7:32 they started it. Older woman working the cash register was snappy. The crust on one pizza was burnt and not edible.

I was charged twice for a tank of gas- I have contacted the manager Michelle 4 times now. She has told me twice that she would call me back after speaking with corporate; I have never rcvd that callback and when I called her, the cashier hung up on me. I drove over back to the station but the manager again was too busy too talk bc she was making pizza. This has been going on now for a week tomorrow. Does Casey condone theft and do you just turn your back on the proof?

Clean store, restrooms, and pump area! We love Casey's Taco Pizza and service is always good.