Carriage House Restaurant

We came here to celebrate a special date night. Our entire experience was wonderful start to finish. The truffle butter rolls and oysters Rockefeller were delicious apps. The star of the show was the Parisian gnocchi that was so savory with subtle apple flavor. The NY strip was cooked perfectly and oh so very tender. We finished the meal with the apple galette which had a great balance of sweet and saltiness with the caramel sauce. Our server Erin was so friendly and knowledgeable and when she saw we couldn’t decide on dessert that she brought a slice of cheesecake with our selection on the house. The cozy atmosphere and attentive staff made our night special. We got reservation a week in advance just so you know!

Had the most amazing dinner here last night. The menu, initially, looked limited but, our waitperson (Erin) explained that there were some specials AND some of the appetizers were available as a full-sized entree. That changed everything for me. My spouse had the pan-fried pollock, and reported it delicious. The green salad appetizer was enough to share, and my shrimp cocktail was perfect. The martini I ordered was large enough to shave in. The bolognese as an entree was yummy. Relaxed atmosphere, personable staff & management. We’ll return at a time we can see the ocean view!

Quaint little restaurant with beautiful and flavorful dishes. Awesome bar/wait staff that are approachable and insightful. Really impressed with the white fish pate, but enjoyed the whole experience. Thank you!

Staying in Rye with family. The Carriage House was within walking distance. Tried to get reservations on Tuesday, the place was filled up on open table really fast. So we made reservations for Wednesday. Such a great meal! Dan was our server and was knowledgeable and a pleasure. The food was outstanding! Soup to nuts one of the favorite new places we’ve tried this year. An ocean gem! We started with delicious oysters and the mushroom toast, (which could be one of the tastiest bites I have experienced ever)! I had the halibut dish, it was summer on a plate with the sweet corn and grilled peaches! My husband had the speck wrapped monkfish, it was beautiful! Highly recommend!

Absolutely a must "go to" if you are in the area! Outstanding, delicious food and drinks! From appetizers to entrees to dessert! Everything is perfect!