Carmelina's Pizzeria and Ristorante

Mmm, mmm,mmmmm!! This place is absolutely AMAZING. We moved to Long Island a couple months ago and have been to other pizzerias in the area and this place, Carmelinas has such amazing, delicious savory food. The garlic knots are a 10/10, the pizza? 10/10 and the heroes are 10/10. And don't forget the zeppoles, during a snow storm you'll be all set with these by your side. Highly recommend this spot and you won't be disappointed!

1st time eating from here since new owners and name change. Was disappointed. Ordered a Sicilian Pie with meatballs and sausage. The bottom was burned, dough was way over worked and not a lot of toppings. Veal parmigiana was way dry, hardly any sauce and the bread was hard.The cinnamon sugar zeppoli’s are hard, and so oily. Don’t think we’ll even give it a second try. If we weren’t so hungry and it was earlier, I would’ve run out to grab something else to eat.

I don’t leave reviews often, but with Carmelina’s I felt the need to do so. I’m so annoyed with myself for living so close to this place and not having gone sooner. Everything about this place is great and they do everything so well at a price that is actually reasonable. Pizza and takeout in general has gotten a bit absurd but I actually felt like I paid less than anywhere else in the surrounding area and the food was soooooo much better. We got pizza, two very different types of pasta which both came with ridic large and delicious salads with house balsamic dressing some mozzarella sticks and garlic bread was also included. Everything delicious, clearly was cooked by people who care and take pride in what they do. This is assuredly my new go to place for pizza and Italian takeout.

Usually love this place their pizza is amazing, decided to try the penne ala vodka today with some fried chicken, the chicken is great the pasta on the other hand is absolutely disgusting, completely dry,95% of it was scallions, and pasta is hard needs to be boiled longer, will never order pasta from them again,wasted $20+

This place is great. Delicious pizza, lots of variety. The staff and owners are so nice. Try the Detroit! The last two times I have been there have been a very different experience than the first time above. A few months back, they didn't even get my order correct and never made the food. I waited thirty minutes to wait for a few different pies. That was a miscommunication, I let that go. Pizza was good. Yesterday, I ordered a pie. Grandma crust, three toppings, well done. Nine slices of square pizza. Over $40 bucks! It was good, not amazing, but good. $40 bucks. Nope. I cannot afford that. I placed it on Slice to pick up, the button is on their website, instead of calling. I should have called, there was a small fee just for using that button as well. I know times are tough and food pric