Carleo Italian Pizza

I will never give a bad review for a restaurant because I used to work in the restaurant industry. I called in two subs, French fries, and a stomboli. I was told 35 minutes. I always allow extra time and went in 50 Minutes to pickup. I got there and was told oh we don’t have your stomboli it will be an extra 15 minutes. I guess I could have accepted this except they offered no discount and my other food had been sitting. Never again. It used to be great here. I will not return. Do yourself a favor and go to Tuscany’s in Emmitsburg

We just made the mistake of giving this place another chance. All our fried food was luke warm and soggy,the pizza took an extra half an hour past the quoted time, the fried zucinni was barely fried, the fries were soggy and grose the mozzarella sticks luke warm at best, we pay to much money for food, alittle care and quality would have been nice. Won't give this place another chance. Tired of bad quality food. Tuscany on the corner in town is better. Or rockys in thurmont. Don't wast your money here.

This is one of the nicest family restaurants I’ve been to in awhile. It is small, only a few tables, but they have a booming pizza and takeout business. We ate in. Their homemade meatlover’s lasagna was awesome. Tasty sauce. Plenty of melted cheese. Lots of meat! Baked perfectly and still bubbling when it was brought to the table. And the meal included a salad! The portion was wonderfully large. Think of a full sized pie tin on a large dinner plate. Talk about value! I had half for dinner and half for today’s lunch. Also, the little loaf of Italian bread was superb. The staff is very friendly and multitasking continually, but not so busy that they won’t check on you regarding how the food is or if you need your drink topped off. In any case, if you’re in Emmitsburg, this is a def

I used to really to love this place. But the last times I ordered was a very bad experience. They don't listen to instructions. I've order wings and had multiple times the sauce leaking out the bag. Food is never consistent. One time you will get it, it will be amazing and the next time it won't. They used to add just enough sauce for wings to where the wings wouldn't be completely devoured with sauce and now they completely fill up the container no matter if u give them instructions. I've had wings completely overcooked, subs soggy and a lot of of inconisentices. Their Italian pasta food is okay I think it lacks flavor but that's just a personal opinion. That's by far their most consistent dish. And one of my favorite things to get their was their fries as they would normally load up the

I left a 5 star review 4 years ago, since then they're reliability to have my order ready on time has plummeted. The food is still great, both the steak and chicken and cheese subs as well as the pizza (sweeter sauce) but I can no longer rely on them to have my order ready on time.