Caldwell House Restaurant

My family enjoyed a Christmas dinner at the CH last night. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warmth. The Cosmo was on point! We got seated fairly quickly given our party was 14 ppl. The food was beautifully presented & prepared. Only thing that was less than desirable was the mushroom gravy, just too salty for me, but otherwise, very tasty. Highly recommend CH for any occasion. They also were able to split the checks (by 4), so there was no mystery or confusion at the end of the meal. And, the holiday decorations and beautifully hearth were the perfect backdrop for all of our treasured family pics 📸

Stopped by by chance & by chance was lucky to get two seats at the bar without a reservation! Our first time here, so we decided to try some apps & a lite dish. The onion soup was loaded with goodies, we both felt the onion soup was good but thought it lacked some color & that beefy-sherry taste that we’ve come to enjoy. The manhattan sandwich was superb, tender & full of flavor as were the fries. The early bird special look wonderful & we’ll be back to try them. Bar staff friendly & engaging. All in all , a great date night.

Visited this establishment for the first time just by driving by because my family and I were hungry. The overall experience was great. The hostess was accommodating to my party of (5). The waitress was kind, courteous and professional. The drinks were great and the food was excellent. It was filling. The Cesar salad with anchovies was different but it was good. Whenever we are back in Lake George, we will visit again.

Visited the area from Indiana. The restaurant was adorable. The waitress was excellent. The food was “interesting.” Husband ordered sirloin, med rare and it was cooked well done. A bit dry. His lobster was good. I ordered the pork shank with blackberry glaze. I couldn’t eat it nor the mashed potatoes due to the glaze over them which did not compliment anything. And the onion rings over everything was a no for me. Our friends, 1 ordered a chicken pasta dish which was just ok. The other ordered t-bone and it was fine, cooked according to the request. Salads were good, bread was very bland. The crackers and spread were delicious. All of the drinks were spot on. I’d say it’s a gamble to eat here which was so disappointing since it had all the ingredients to make for an excellent experience.

We had an amazing experience at this steak house! It had a great atmosphere, delicious food and very friendly staff. Nikia was our server and she is probably the best waitress I have ever met, she was very positive, very attentive and made great recommendations for our whole family. Definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a great meal and a wonderful experience.