Calabash Caribbean Grill – Two Notch Road

UPDATE 10/28/ 2025**** I visited Calabash a few days ago and the oxtails( plentiful) , plantains, cabbage and rice& beans were delicious. Overall everything was just as good as before with the exception of the "cheesecake" which was horrible. And since this wasn't my first time trying it, I'm gonna have to change the 5 stars to 3 stars. It was hard ( you had to chisel a piece off ) and it was bland and stale. I.M.O....the store bought cheesecake, even Walmart is better. And to my surprise , the entrees have increased ( $3-4.00 more). 🤔 I know you get what you pay for, but that's a little too steep for my pockets when the dessert (cheesecake) isn't up to par. ***** (Previous Post)**** MY MY, MY. This place left me speechless, or should I say the oxtails did. The seasoning was perfect

I come here a lot. Usually the St Andrews Location. Usually there good 10/10 but tonight wasn’t it. Not sure who in the kitchen. They need that older lady with the glasses around. This night I didn’t see her and the chicken was bad. It was more like beef jerky on a bone. Everything else was good. This just a reminder to never get comfortable. Peace and blessings

I received a Door Dash order in January 2026 when I was still a patient at Prisma Heart Hospital. I always judge a Caribbean Restaurant by how they prepare Jerk Chicken. It's the 2nd worse Jerk chicken plate I've eaten in my 50yrs of life. Not only was parts of the chicken burnt to the point of being inedible, it wasn't fresh. Tasting like leftovers that was prepared a few days prior. Never again! This restaurant does not deserve its 4 star (3.8)rating based on my experience.

I ordered deliver thru Door Dash tonight. The packaging is very messy. The sauce overflows the slots. The Oxtails have a good taste (which is the only reason there's a 2nd star) and the sauce helped, but the white rice was very dry and not at all enjoyable. The steaed vegetables were mushy. Plus, +$4.00 for a side of mac & cheese that was dry, old, and too salty. Would not buy from here again

Let me start by saying I have never had an issue with Calabash. However, I purchased 2 Curry Goat Dinners and paid almost 60.00 to get home to a plate full of rice. Potatoes and two small pieces of goat meat. The lady preparing the food was the same one who checked us out. She took a long time so obviously she was scooping out the potatoes and not the meat and then put a bunch of gravy on the plate. For 28.00 gor one plate and to get served that was ridiculous