Cakey Cakes & Bagels

We couldn’t have been happier with our wedding cake from Cakey Cakes Bakery! From the very beginning, they were kind, professional, and so easy to work with. We felt completely at ease knowing they had everything under control, and they absolutely delivered. The cake was not only beautiful, it was delicious. Seriously, we’re still getting compliments from guests about how good it tasted (and we may or may not have saved an extra slice for ourselves). The design was exactly what we had envisioned, elegant, clean, and perfectly matched to our theme. If you’re looking for a bakery that truly cares about getting every detail right and will give you both peace of mind and a stunning final product, Cakey Cakes is the one. They made a sweet part of our day even sweeter, and we’re so grateful!

The chocolate-covered donuts are amazing, and the pumpkin roll was excellent as well! I also tried the everything bagel. You can really taste the quality. The bagel was handmade and authentic, just like in NYC. Definitely try the bagels; it is so rare to find a place that actually hand-rolls them!

Went in for a variety of bagels based on a recommendation. When we got there they were out of what we wanted. The owner graciously offered to take our list and have us come back in 30-40 minutes as they were making fresh bagels. We accepted, we don't live far. OMG! Best breakfast decision in a while. How were we sleeping on these bagels. We ordered a dozen, we tried to get one of each. We split them amongst five of us so we could sample a small bite of them all. ALL, even the ones they already had prepared were soft and delicious. Typically I enjoy sweet over savory, but these are ALL amazing. Would love to give a favorite, but I can't decide on one. The cream cheeses are delish too. We are adding a new favorite to our list of breakfast bites.

Not sure what went wrong with my wedding cake. Weddings are stressful but there was only one thing I was unhappy with and it was my wedding cake. I didn’t want to post this but it keeps bothering me that I spent that much money on something I didn’t ask for. We showed a picture, gave great detail and coloring and the opposite was done. It was like whoever did it just did whatever they wanted. It didn’t match my wedding colors at all. It’s like they really didn’t listen to me or something just went wrong. 180 dollars could have bought a lot of pretty cupcakes at Sam’s club. Also paid for a stand to borrow for our cake and our cake wouldn’t even fit on it. It was a disaster. We had no time to fix the issue being that we were busy being a part of our own wedding. Pretty disappointing that day

I cannot express enough gratitude to Cakey Cakes & Bagels for their exceptional service and the outstanding cake they created. Despite my short notice for a birthday order, they were incredibly accommodating and took the time to craft a beautiful cake. The final product was not only visually stunning but also fresh and delicious. I highly recommend this company and will undoubtedly utilize their services for any future events. If it were possible to give more than 5 stars, I would certainly rate them 10+++ stars! Thank you so much! 💛