Caffe Italia Trattoria

When you're Italian and cook all the time, it's tough to crave someone else's food. But Cafe Italian is the exception!Their dishes are always amazing, the atmosphere's great, and the service is top-notch. Whether you're sticking to the menu or trying the nightly specials, you can't go wrong. The food is just amazing Trust me, I'd give it a solid 10 - love this place!"

I ordered meatballs. They were so dry I almost choked. Had half a meatball. Then bees were all over them. I was still charged for the meatballs even tho I had half a one. Lol money isn't an issue but the point is I didnt like it nor did I eat it. Apparently people in Marblehead enjoy eating bugs because the waitress kept asking if I wanted the nasty bee covered meatballs wrapped up. Honestly, the fries were the worst. I adore rosemary and there was literally black crumbs on the fries I thought was black pepper. I said where is the rosemary he said "that black stuff is rosemary". Nooooo. Don't waste your money here. You'll be disappointed greatly.

Welcoming to us as we are celebrating our return trip … the staff was great.. Amy was perfect in her service accommodating to our needs! The scallops were perfect ..& the salmon was a light meal for our dining! Donna, the owner was very welcoming & friendly! We highly recommend this lovely restaurant!

Came here for the first time tonight. I really enjoyed my meal, as did my friend. We shared the prosciutto and burrata appetizer, seared scallops with butternut squash risotto (a special), and the pork chop Milanese. We were super impressed with the risotto and scallops. Scallops were cooked perfectly, very flavorful and the risotto was buttery, cheesy and only a little bit sweet. Loved the other dishes too. I rarely drink with dinner, but ordered a lemon drop martini when I saw one being delivered to another table. I'm glad I did - it was the perfect balance of sweet and sour. Will definitely come back and recommend to others.

One of our favorites. Staff is attentive and always very friendly and welcoming. The food and drink never disappoint. Must tries…Joel rolls, arugula beet salad and chicken parm. Oh, and don’t forget an espresso martini. Great menu and drink selection. Other must tries are the eggplant rollatini, chix or veal saltimbocca and haddock francaise. I wish there was a way to give them 6 stars…this place deserves it!