Buffy's Ice Cream Cafe

This is a phenomenal homemade ice cream spot in an incredible location. In Chatham, Buffy's provides creamy, rich ice cream and a variety of flavors at a fair price. The staff there was very kind and sincere in providing help for an allergy in my party--something that goes a long way. The ice cream itself was also very tasty and well-sized. Another big plus: this place is not cash only. Would recommend, and I will be back.

Lovely little ice cream spot, the blueberry cheesecake flavour is unreal !! the ice cream bars are also very nice, we tried the chatham light bar and defo recommend if you like cookie dough

Reviews said it was the best ice cream on the Cape and I am now a believer! Both sandwich and ice cream parts of our treats were amazing. Service was quick and friendly, outside setting is well kept and shady. Well worth the detour we took to enjoy Buffy’s sandwiches.

Stopped into Buffy’s Ice Cream Café in Chatham and had an amazing experience! Nolan gave fantastic service and suggested I try the Salted Caramel Affogato—absolutely spectacular. The balance of the sweet ice cream with the rich espresso was perfect. Highly recommend—this place is a must-stop if you’re in Chatham!

The ice cream sandwiches are sooo yum! The staff was friendly and helpful. It’s expensive but what isn’t in the area!