Brothers Brew Coffee Shop

Need to give Brothers Brew a shout out! Excellent gourmet coffee selections with a nice selection of tasty treats. The atmosphere matches the taste and coffees. A nice place to stop and sit for a bit after walking around this quaint little town.

This establishment was amazing! We visited here for a light breakfast and coffee. The atmosphere was chill and peaceful. The food was fantastic! Try the skillets and burritos. So much to choose from!

Brothers Brew is a local favorite with a homey atmosphere and the only place that was open in the historic district on a Tuesday for lunch on this day in November. They have a nice selection of offerings, some very creative. You order at the nostalgic counter and later, your name is called and your plates are delivered to your seats. We opted for a Pastrami and a Reuben, both on marbled rye, loaded with nice gooey cheese. I would have liked it better if it had been grilled with butter. Think they skipped the Russian dressing. Utz chips ok as was the sliced pickle. Nice friendly staff. We would return.

The food was really disappointing. The beef Reuben was drenched in dressing, making the bread soggy, and the donuts were nothing special. For what we got, paying over $50 was insane. On top of that, the service wasn’t great — after waiting about 30 minutes in a long line, our order was messed up. Even though we said we were eating onsite, everything was packed in to-go bags, and no one called our name, so our food sat there getting cold. Definitely not worth the wait or the price.

The breakfast sandwiches we had were very delicious and worth every penny. Not sure if they make the bagels themselves but they tasted very fresh and unlike store bought. The iced coffee I ordered was not good. It tasted old and funky. It had a weird film on it. I bet their espresso drinks would have been much better. Go with that choice if you want coffee there.