Brooklyn Brisket

Brooklyn Brisket is one of those rare places that gets everything right without trying too hard. From the moment we walked in, the staff was genuinely warm and welcoming. When they found out it was our first visit, they happily offered samples-no pressure, just pride in what they do. That alone says a lot. Everything is made to order, and you can taste the care in every bite. Nothing rushed, nothing reheated-just solid, honest food done right. Portions are generous, quality is high, and the pricing is more than fair for what you get. This place feels like it was built on craft, kindness, and consistency. Utica's lucky to have it. We'll absolutely be back.

Came from FL on vacation and we decided to come in and I am so glad we did. The owner was so very nice and the sample of the brisket over rice compared to other places is very generous. Overall the food was amazing and the green hot sauce just hit the spot.

We found Brooklyn Brisket & Deli via Google whist driving through Utica so decided to stop by and try their Brisket. They have only been open for a few months but it seems like a popular spot. Whilst we were deciding on what to order they gave us 2 very generous samples of rice, lettuce and brisket! That’s not something we are used to it was very generous of them. The Brooklyn Cheese Burger was luscious and hearty and barely held together inside the bun. Flavour met expectations for Brooklyn brisket and did not disappoint. The staff are wonderful. I have a severe allergy to green bell peppers and the staff made sure my Sandwich didn’t have any. There isn’t much seating. No bathrooms are available. Off street parking is available but limited.

8/27/25 Update the manager brazel called me & apologized & offered to replace whole meal. He said they were out of peppers & onions.. I appreciate him contacting me as I was very upset. Food received was still 1 star, but will upgrade service to 3 stars until I get meal replaced. Do not recommend to any one. Terrible service. Ordered delivery via grubhub they completely messed up my order. Requested white sauces & hot sauce on side. My lamb over rice came covered in white sauce. My brisket cheesesteak was so small and had lettuce & tomatoe no peppers, onions, cheese. The cheese fries were not covered in a soft cheddar sauce, cheese was hard. I called owner & explained the issues, he could of cared less. Said person who made food already left, I asked if he was going to correct these issu

This restaurant has a very nice view. When you're having a meal there, you can see the famous murals of Utica. When you enter this restaurant and don't know what to order, they will prepare a sample for you to taste. The smiles of the staff are very warm, and they treat the food seriously. I believe you will have a unique experience here. How about it? Let's communicate with them and offer some suggestions to help them improve.