Broken Tree Taproom & Pizza of Appleton

Had the pizza buffet for lunch on Friday. Got there at 11:20 and pizzas weren't out yet but they came out shortly after arriving. First couple pizzas were a little well done but the rest were very good. Definitely are too much.

Pizza was amazing! The crust was exactly as I was hoping for as far as Neapolitan style. We had two pizzas. We tried the Thats Life pizza which had the perfect amount of spice finished with the sweetness of the balsamic glaze. Also the Hailey’s Comet which had the creamy garlic sauce and that was delicious as well. Love hearty sauce and all the garlic. The cheese sticks were perfect too. Can’t pick which pizza was better. Everything was great. Our service and server Sky were also excellent. Timely with everything and fun to chat with. Would highly recommend it. It will be hard to try somewhere new after eating here.

Got to taste local brews, from the the long list of draft beer. Locations was great as I went during winter not able to enjoy the river side setup

Food was very tasty! Loved the margarita pizza and the garlic strips with peppercorn dip! Our server, Sky, was also very helpful and amazing! Thank you!!

So I've been here for pizza 3 times in less than two weeks, and I wouldn't call myself the biggest pizza person generally, but the pizza here feels like a craft pizza experience more than a quick bake pizza place. They make beautiful and delicious pies. I've gotten a different type of pizza each time and have loved every one. The most recent being the Fun Guy (my new favorite pizza in Appleton). The staff has been great, super friendly, and attentive every time. I'm sure I'll be back sooner rather than later.