Brenz Pizza Co New Albany

My son and daughter in law have been telling us to try your pizza, they love it. A couple of days ago we ordered it and took home. The pizza crust was very good. We were a little disappointed in the rest. Hardly any toppings compared to the picture on website. We got the ATM

⭐️⭐️½ – Great Basil. Mid Chicken. Manage Your Expectations. 📍 Brenz Pizza Co. – 4861 Tuttle Crossing Blvd, Columbus, OH 🗓️ Visit: August 2025 🥡 Ordered: • Heritage Honey Pizza (me) • Loaded Pep & Cheese Pizza (dining partner) • 5-piece Hot Buffalo BBQ Wings (new flavor, not listed on menu) ⸻ 🍕 PIZZA • Crust: Fluffy and doughy — almost too bready. If you like a pillowy crust, you’ll be fine. If you prefer structure or crunch, this might feel underwhelming. • Sauce: I requested a mix of red sauce and garlic butter base, but neither flavor came through. I only knew it was there because I could see it — not taste it. • Heritage Honey: Sounded better than it tasted. Ingredients didn’t blend well — basil was the only real standout. • Hot honey drizzle: Syrupy, overly thick, not as spicy or bal

I ordered the chefs salad and let's just say it was delicious and large enough to share with 1 other person. I was extremely surprised on how big the bowl is and how delicious it was.

Picked the old world and Bianca pie from here and enjoyed both pies. Meatballs on the old world were almost like meatloaf and turned out well this visit. Both hearty pies so it does take a lot to get full. Will be back and worth a try.

Ordered pizzas today for all my workers at Zoom Express and Nate took special care of my team and added some cookies. Great to have good neighbors that look out for each others hard workers. The pizza is damn good as well.