Benny Stivale's Pizza

The only size pizza here looks to be two feet across. Each slice takes up two paper plates and it’s delicious. They even sell ginger beer and have a claw machine.

Delicious food, fun atmosphere and friendly staff. The slices are HUGE! Closest thing to NY pizza we could find in Waynesboro.

Being from the Northeast I was a little skeptical. I have been fortunate in my business travels to have eaten Pizza in Long Island, CT, Boston, Philadelphia, Chicago, Brooklyn etc. first bite was wow. Real cheese, tangy, and a crust alone that could be a meal. Excellent. Slices are huge 15” long by 10” wide.

Would not recommend trying to eat this driving 🤣. Awesome pizza

A pizza 28" in size and actually good is fantastic. The pepperoni and mushrooms I usually order are generous and very good quality. The sauce and cheese very good as well. Either a whole pie or single slice, it is always cooked correctly and fresh. Not a huge soggy mess like many other large pizzas. It is done quickly and if you call ahead it has always been done when they say. Friendly staff and I like the location and shop as well. The restaurant is a very cool spot to eat and relax with a beer or root beer and if you need something sweet there is gelato. For what you get it is worth every penny. Have room in your car, she is a big one. I was recently back for a full pie and was again very pleased with the service and the food. I love that these places exist. This is not Domino's, thank