Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs

I really didn't wanna leave a bad review but tried calling this store on 3 different occasions and flat out no answer. No matter the time of day. Here goes. I went there Monday 02/09/26 to pick up lunch for my girlfriend and me. I ordered a number 4 combination and a grilled veggie, both footlongs. My number 4 was not only missing the extra cheese that comes with it but it was missing the extra I asked for on top of what comes with it. I even asked the lady if it had extra cheese when she handed me the bag. When I arrived home to open the subs starting with mine. There wasn't even cheese covering the whole sub, much less Xtra. Now, the grilled veggie was literally a loaf of bread with maybe half containing a tiny bit of grilled veggies. This was a busy time for the store and I had asked f

Very nice, sandwich was delicious. Order 1/2 America Army extra onions 🍅 and mayo. Will be opening on Sundays 11-4 super nice people, make sandwiches as you like

I called today and asked if I could make a pickup order and was told no I had to make it online, while a little upset bc I've done it before recently with the new management. But that was okay I was on the way there anyways.... I pull in at 11am exactly to find then closed but workers inside. So .... When I called about 10 minutes before and was told I had to make the order online... What if I did ... How the hell was I supposed to get my order? Very unprofessional, very upsetting, and very much need better management then what the supposed new ones.

13 orders backed up, averaging 1 sandwich every 10 minutes. The past 10 customers have been told they are not taking anymore orders until they catch up. Took an hour to get my food, at least it was tasty.

I had an amazing experience at Baldinos Jersey Subs in Garden City! The food was fresh and delicious—exactly what you expect from a great sub shop. But what really stood out was the service. Harry and Gee were absolutely excellent, friendly, professional, and made sure everything was perfect. They went above and beyond to make my visit enjoyable. Definitely my go-to spot from now on!