Athens Square Cafe

We had gyros, spinach pie, humus, crab cakes, and some desserts. Best humus and souvlaki sauce I’ve ever had, even got lucky enough to taste the rice pudding right after it was made, and that chocolate moose cake was out of this world. Everything was delicious and fresh. Can’t wait to try other menu items. Very friendly and polite owner and staff! It’s a tragedy I missed out on this place for the many years I’ve lived in Northport. Definitely will become a regular now and treat our guests when they come to visit. No photos since every dish looked super yummy so I got busy stuffing my face. 😅

Food was terrible and highly overpriced!! They charge 15 dollars for a pita with pork meat and the pita is tiny. They do add a good amount of meat in it but the meat is as hard as cardboard. More like dog food than anything else. They also have souvlaki on the menu but it isn’t the typical skewers it’s just cubed pork meat that again is as hard as rock and grossly overpriced. I was charged 25 dollars for about 15 cubes. Needless to say we paid 60 dollars for 2 small pitas, 2 souvlakia and a coke!! Freekin ridiculous. Don’t know what these people are thinking but I’m pretty sure they wont be around for long.

I don’t know what happened to this place. They are the tiniest little gyros and the most expensive around. When my wife came home and told me how much she spent on four gyros, I was absolutely appalled when I took them out of the bag and they fit in the palm of my hand. I understand things might be a little tough, but ripping people off is absolute BS.

Gyro was great, soup was awful! Basically lemon water with a tiny bit of celery and carrots and a tiny bit of orzo. If I was eating it there it certainly would have went back

$60 for Burger and Salad. Way Overpriced and overrated. Take your money elsewhere