Anthony's Pizza

Anthony’s is our go-to place for pizza! I can’t say enough good things about them…Not only is their food amazing but the entire staff is just incredible! Our faves include the Buffalo Mac and cheese pizza, chicken Caesar salad pizza, chicken scampi pie and the street corn pizza (get a slice if you see it!) and of course the sandwiches on garlic rolls and the Anthony’s salad😋. Make sure you grab at least one zeppoli too! EDIT: This is the second time we catered a party from Anthony’s - their wrap and sub platters were an absolute hit! Highly recommend. Thanks guys!

Very nice staff and cooks. Pizza is less like northern jersey or NYC pizza and more like the shore pizza which is always very heavy with salt and cheese. Two slices will have ya dehydrated and full. If ya want the nyc or north nj pizza this ain’t it. But if you like a LOT of cheese and salt. With good toppings and a lot of them. This is your spot!

Moved to Wall Twp. five years ago. My usual go to spot for pizza & subs had 2 price increases in one year. I was looking for a new place and found Anthony's via Google search. I was impressed with their ratings & reviews. I ordered sausage parmigiana or chicken parmigiana subs and they're out of this world! Tasty sausage/chicken, delicious sauce, fresh bread and a hearty/heavy sub at a VERY reasonable price. Has been my go to for two months and will continue ordering from them. Highly recommend !!

When I ordered it was great the girl was helpful and polite. That’s pretty much where it ended. My sandwich the chicken was so hard I couldn’t eat 3/4 of it. I also asked for light sauce it was covered in sauce. I’m not a complainer but I paid $17 for a small sandwich that I couldn’t even eat from the chicken being so hard. Then the soda top wasn’t on all the way partially my fault for not double checking but the cap off and I wore the drink. The place was nice clean just need to do better in the chicken maybe it was over cooked or reheated but very hard good portions if it was able to be eaten. It’s worth a try just be careful with the chicken hopefully they will redeem themselves with some of the pizzas they had next time.

Very good pizza place, wide variety of menu options, nice staff and super supportive of our local disc golf club. Jesus and staff are all good people- highly recommended!