Andy's Frozen Custard

Mmm... strong with the flavor, this one is. A true delight, my Build-Your-Own Concrete Mixer was—crafted with the Force of frozen perfection and powered by Reese’s Pieces and Peanut Butter Cups. Rich, creamy custard mixed thoroughly, toppings well-balanced and generously portioned. Satisfied, my sweet tooth was. Swift and friendly, the staff were—like Padawans of hospitality. No long wait, no disturbance in the dessert Force. Just smooth, efficient service and a cupful of galactic-level goodness. Recommend this spot, I do, to all seekers of frozen bliss in the galaxy. For a peanut butter lover, this is the way.

This is one of my top favorite places for ice cream! Every time I visit the Midwest, I make sure to stop by. Everything is delicious but I especially love the concretes!

First time at Andy’s after my son had urged me to try as a new local in Saint Louis. Andy’s is a walk up location with a few bench seats on the front. Parking was no problem and the area clean. They had steady business the whole time we were there on a Saturday evening. A large menu board with large variety of custard treats makes it easy to decide on an order before moving to the window. I decided on a butter pecan. My wife got a concrete Oreo variety. Warning the small is good size. The large is shareable. The price point seems competitive to others. The order cranked out in about 5 minutes. My wife really enjoyed hers. I liked mine, but was not as good imo as Ted Drew’s. Andy was much thicker, however great flavor. I prefer a smoother custard. I would return and recommend.

Honestly far one of the worst experiences I had. First I had to asked them for my stuff several times and I had a lot of stuff and they couldn’t even offer a tray another thing they got my order wrong and I had to tell them and they also didn’t gave me everything I had to go back and ask them. Also the lady at the counter was on her phone on face time while I wouldn’t care that they’re on the phone but they weren’t doing a great job so it just shows how they shouldn’t. Also the latte was horrible wasn’t even full like they show on the picture and the whole things was the custard with ice on top couldn’t even drink it with the straw.

We have been here over twenty times this year, as well as to other locations. Normally it is a great experience. Tonight - not so much. Terrible customer service. Employees kept vanishing into the back, skipping items, forgetting entire orders. One female employee tonight closed the window directly in our face rather than listen to a problem with the order. Please do better.