Amorino Gelato - New York Times Square

Updated Review My initial visit on 9/5/25 was not pleasant and resulted in me walking out and leaving a 1star review. On Sunday 11/16/25, I was invited back for another visit, after management reached out concerning my first experience. Thank you to Jim V whom instructed me to return and ask for Kaylee, this visit was definitely a better experience. Kaylee was the sweetest, helpful and impressionable. She provided the engaging service that was originally missing. After walking me thru the menu and even providing some of her personal suggestions, Kaylee helped me select a couple of items to try. Thank you Kaylee. Based on my second experience, I am now inclined to give Amorino Gelato another chance when in the area again for a broadway show. Just A Note: I hope that my future experie

Cozy, rustic gelato shop with warm wood beams and a charming, well-lit case packed with unique flavors. The space feels inviting and unhurried—perfect for lingering with a cup. The staff were incredibly sweet and patient while I sampled and decided, walking me through their favorites and how the flavors are made. I landed on hazelnut-chocolate, pistachio, and tiramisu. All three were silky and dense and blended beautifully in one cup—each bite balanced but distinct. It’s the most incredible gelato I’ve ever had, and the cozy atmosphere makes it even better. I’m already planning a return visit!

Really good gelato! Tastes very creamy and rich :) loved the service Nicky and Kaley gave me. Asked both in flavor recommend as well as best flavors combo. Definitely must come back for the affogato and try.

Amorino Gelato in Times Square was such a treat! The staff was friendly, the flavors were rich and creamy, and the presentation was beautiful. Perfect stop in the middle of the Times Square buzz. Definitely worth it! 🍨✨

Really good gelato! I definitely recommend getting their specialty hot chocolate with gelato inside omg it is to die for! Also really good crepes.