Amicci's Pizza

The food is overpriced. I ordered a deep dish pizza and received something with the exact thickness as a Little Caesars Hot And Ready (for $25). And yes, I had a Little Caesars Hot n Ready in hand to make the comparison. I'm the photo there is the hot and ready and the "deep dish" you tell me which is a deep dish.

We have been ordering from Amicci's for over 15 YEARS. When the pizza is made the way you order it, it is the best pie around! Sadly, the odds of getting what you ordered continue to be surprisingly unlikely and have been for years (even WELL before the pandemic). More times than not (no exaggeration - MORE times than NOT), the pizza arrives missing SOMETHING. Today it was missing mushrooms (as pictured). Extra pizza Sauce was also invoiced but the pizza arrived dry and had hardly any sauce on it (which is why we make sure to order EXTRA). The mushroom addition was a $2 upcharge on the extra-large and there was NO mushroom on the pizza. You'll see a lot below about wanting to do better and wanting to call and 'make it right', but from our experience, it's just lip service. If they truly wa

We went to Nancy a whiskey’s one night to meet up with friends. Their kitchen was closed. It was suggested r to order Amicci’s Pizza. Wow. Their pizza was the bomb!! It was a huge pizza and fed our entire group. The crust was soft and so so yummy. Can’t wait to try different things on their menu! Yum!!

To the crew that was working at 10pm today... incredible job. Wish I knew y'all's names so I could shout you out. Great experience, and I haven't had a pizza that good in a long time, and I eat pizza all the time.

Been a long time since I’ve found a spot that gave me food worth my money. Everything seems to be shrinking, but the price. The deals here are definitely reasonable. The pizza here is pretty good. I ordered the XL Cheese Pizza w/ Garlic Butter Crust & Butter-Parm All Over as well as an XL Pepperoni.