American Melts

I went in because of the hype. But I was the first person there on Tuesday morning. Got the buffalo chicken and cheesesteak Cooper cheese. I only ate a quarter of each because they’re big as hell. My tastebuds wanted me to finish eating both sandwiches entirely lol so since I ate a half a sandwich it was just half cheesesteak Cooper cheese and the other half buffalo chicken. The buffalo chicken is cubed pieces of breast meat, so don’t think you’re gonna get thinly sliced cheesesteak but in a chicken form, which is what I thought. So it’s very filling! It doesn’t have an overpowering buffalo taste which is great and I’m a person who loves spicy food and buffalo sauce is no problem. But I think they did this just right, so anybody who’s not a fan of buffalo can still get this and enjoy it gr

Looking for a great melted grilled cheese sandwich? American Melts off of Route 22 in Kennelworth, NJ is the place to be. easy parking, walk up to the window and check out the menu's multiple types of sandwiches they make. Start by creating your own if your not in a rush. Check out the Special sandwich menu that includes the Mac and cheese, Brie, Ruben, Big Tex and so on. You won't be disappointed. They even include Vegan options as well. You can order online for easy pickup and they're open 7 days a week. We love the create your own grill cheese process as well. The tater tots and Mac and cheese are pretty impressive to. Plenty of breads to choose from including "Gluten free" items. Highly recommended. Enjoy!😊🍽🥪🧈🧀🥓🍞🥖🤤😋

I am not a melt sandwich person, but after my 1st bite, I couldn't stop myself from finishing the entire sandwich. It's delicious with very nice service.

What an awesome place! We got three “design your own” grilled cheese sandwiches taking our cues from some of the existing combos. The rye bread is fantastic. Fresh ingredients in perfect proportions, friendly staff. You can’t ask for much more. I’ll be back.

The guy told me stony pony is the most popular.. first time here and it tastes amazing!!! I would definitely come back and try other sandwiches.. true gem of NJ.. the people working there are super nice!