Amato's Pizza

We just moved to a new location and we are looking for our new go to pizzeria and I think we hit the jackpot. This was our 3rd time ordering there to make sure it wasn’t a fluke and we have gotten 10/10 food every time. More importantly in my opinion is the customer service. Everyone is friendly when you call them on the phone and greets you with a smile when you walk in. I look for an establishment that has happy employees first and foremost since I’ve personally worked in customer service all my life. Great job Amato’s. You’ve just earned a new regular customer!

***2025 UPDATE*** Had to knock Amato's down to 2 stars. I came in and ordered 2 slices of buffalo chicken pizza. When I was served them at the table they looked the same as when I checked them out at the counter. The bottom was slightly crispy but the cheese and the chicken and even the blue cheese sauce was cold to the touch. The cheese was still congealed. This was around 1pm and the 1st thing I ate all day so I ate the first slice and started on the 2nd. The waitress came back to check in and I said did they reheat the slices and she said yes for a few seconds because people complained they get too crispy if we reheat them too long. I said well they are cold. You even served them on an ice cold metal tray. She said you should have said something sooner I would have had them thro

I love the food here but I wish they would stop taking my slices out the oven so early. They seriously only let them cook for like a minute or 2 then put the lukewarm slices in the box. The cheese isn't even melted on them half the time and when I get home I have to reheat them again because they are already cold. I'm not in a rush and you aren't that busy when I come to get food. Take your time and let my stuff cook!

Ordered food in a snow storm...came back to pick it up and the lady tells me they didnt know what happened to it than says oh we figured it out the delievery person took the wrong food. The only solution was to wait to make another one. Another 20 minutes?!! The solution should of been free food or at least a discount. Such a shame because pur family really like their pizza. NEVER GOING THERE AGAIN!

Ok first of all I do not give bad reviews.Let me explain why I feel that it is necessary.I ordered a Strumboli and was told to wait 25 minutes to pick it up.Keep in mind it is a snow storm so Im worried that might be to long,but decided to go with it.I left to go get things at Target and on my way back it was rough.I barely made it,but I go in and pay for my Strumboli they had the receipt,but no Strumboli?They were scrambling to figure it out and it was a whole bunch of shrugging shoulders.Im watching it unfold in real time and Im told that it is unfortunately missing?No explanation.The last thing I want to do in a snow storm is wait another half hour.I cant even if I wanted to.The manager the women that took my order said I dont know what happened.Later she told me when I called back tell