Alfie's Pizza

I ordered two large pies from Alfies. Both pies were burnt and inedible. I also ordered an eggplant parm sub-It was the worst quality food I've ever had from a pizzeria! I called the restaurant to get my money back and they hung up on me once I calmly explained the situation. Terrible customer service. I will not be ordering again.

I gotta go 5 stars on this place. I don't know why I'm trying this food for the first time or why I never heard of Alfie's but wow I'm glad It popped up on door dash!! First off the taste alone is worth giving it 5 stars! We both are getting two meals out of our one order And can you believe the prices!! I honestly thought my wife was kidding me when she was reading the menu prices!! This is now our go to for delicious Italian food at ridiculously low prices.

Garlic knots are absolutely amazing however because of my love for cheese the boli is the winner of the two items we ordered. In the aspect of cheese to bread ratio ten out of ten. Would like to see this town during daylight hours and have a genuine impression of a seemingly quaint city nestled in the mountains of Penns' Woods.

I had a slice of the Sicilian and a new york style. Both were extremely tasty! The Sicilian had a crispy undercarriage, zero flop and every bite was delicious! The new york style had minimal flop and the amount of sauce and cheese complimented each other well. It's a gem of a place in Leighton and I will definitely be coming back for more! Sicilian 8.1 New york 8.5

Despite being extremely busy they were quick and efficient with out order. The prices were great. We got 3 slices, mozzarella sticks, garlic knots, pepperoni rolls and 2 drinks and our order was around $20. Staff was very courteous.