White Buffalo Pub and Pizza Co.

Boy oh boy, where do I begin. This place is rough and I would recommend others avoid for any other option in this area. We chose this place after a long day of hiking and we were ready to have (big) personal pizzas. I must eat gluten free and this place had options so we went for it. We waited to be sat for about 10ish minutes (with only 2 other parties eating in the restaurant, it was not busy). Then we waited another 10 minutes to get menus. We order drinks and pizza. Takes another long stint before our (canned beers) drinks came out. Pizza took another 20 or so minutes after that. We had no plates or silverware offered or napkins on our table. We had to get it ourselves and ask for this. IT WAS SO BAD Y'ALL. I took one bite and boxed the rest. Hoping I can add some sauce to it at home

Every time I’m in Grand Lake, I always make time to get White Buffalo. The service is excellent and correct every time, even if the restaurant is busy my server Kristen is always kind and professional. Often when I’m there it’s only 1-2 working so I understand that waiting for a minute is worth it for the delicious food and drinks. I wish I could give a higher rating because of how much I love White Buffalo!

Our pizza and salad was great. We came just a day before they closed for the season. Very pricy is the only reason I don’t give 5 stars

Amazing! Delicious food every time! The staff are welcoming and attentive, making the experience for customers super enjoyable. A great spot for tasty food and good company whether it’s out with friends, date night, or treating yourself! Highly recommended!

Very bad. Ordered takeout. 1 large pizza and 12 chicken wings = $84 - I was prepared for tourist town pricing, but not $3 for each topping I added. (I made my own supreme basically) The pizza was subpar with very chewy crust and minimal flavor. The wings were big, but very slimy and barely sauced. Don't get ripped off!