Water Street Tavern

Great quality food! I’ve been a couple times now and tried some of the sandwiches and sides, they were amazing! Definitely wish fresh fries were still an option, brew fries just aren’t my thing. The new rendition of the “Stargell” is good but nothing like it was. I’ve kept in mind it’s different owners and better quality food and I’ve tried original food that they’ve brought in and the renditions they’ve made on previous items, I’d say it’s definitely a restaurant to keep going back to!

if i could give the food zero stars i would. it took about 10min for us to be acknowledged we were not given menus when we sat down so we had to wait longer for someone to come back with those. we sat in the bar area because it was packed (don’t know why considering it’s not that great there) the bar area is super tight and you barely have room to move when you are sat down. ordered drinks and wanted coke the waitress did not tell us they only have pepsi products and just brought out a pepsi instead. fine i’ll drink a pepsi but it would’ve been nice for them to say sorry we only have pepsi. i got the saucy chicken mac n cheese and it was… just not restaurant food. i could’ve made better at home. the noodles were basically plain noodles with milk? and melted shredded cheese over a portion o

Wife and I just ate here for the first time under new ownership. The food was "FANTASTIC"! Extremely satisfied! We will be returning! Thank you!

We were excited to try the new restaurant in town and visited with friends that were visiting from North Carolina. I don't think I'll ever return! We went with the perspective that they recently opened, but with that in mind I would think they would want to impress people to keep them coming back. We ordered: Crabby Dip: We enjoyed this, however it came out only minutes before our meal and we were given 4 obviously dirty plates. When the waitress came back we told her the plates were given to use dirty, she responded with a slight noise and nothing more as she took them and walked away. BBQ Pork Chop with Green Beans and Mashed Potatoes: This was by far the worst plate of food overall I have ever gotten in my life. While the pork chop was juicy with an okay flavor, the mashed potatoes

Stopped in for lunch. New interior looks great! Staff seemed happy to see us and seated us promptly. You could tell at the first bite of my burger that it was fresh and cooked to my liking. The fries were hot, crispy, perfectly done. Checked on us twice for satisfaction of food! Very good all around. 👍