Walter's Deli

Best lobster roll on the island bar none. First ate here in 2022 and was our first stop when we came back in 2025 & it’s just as great with its delicious Texas toast style bread and amazingly generous lobster portions. I got it twice in my week visit both hot and cold versions and loved them equally. WORTH THE PRICE! Get it with some Nantucket crisps, a crunchy soda or lemonade, and grab a bench to enjoy in front of the whaling museum while people watching!

This was my first stop at Nantucket. I got to try the Reuben and a cold Lobster roll. The service was quick and easy. The sandwiches both tasted great and it was like getting a nice intro to Nantucket. Small place with no seating. Just takeout only.

Had the Lobster Roll, cold w/ mayo. Enough said. This warm split top buttered roll with a cold generous amount of fresh lobster was amazing. We are on the island working the cold months & this was amazing!!! Can't wait to be back in a couple weeks!! Oh, the God Father sub & the Meatball sub are delicious too!!! Can't go wrong here!!!

Excellent sandwiches (especially the Reuben) and might be the best lobster roll I had between Newport, Cuttyhunk, Martha’s Vineyard, and Nantucket. Would heartily recommend.

The lobster roll here is fantastic and full of lobster. I got it cold, but it is available hot or cold. The bun is warm on the ‘cold’ style. The watermelon juice is delicious and super refreshing on a hot summer day.