Wally's Bagel Cafe, Northvale

Absolutely unacceptable. This place should be ashamed of itself. The pricing on the menu is flat-out misleading — what’s listed is NOT what you’re charged. When questioned, the staff responds with attitude instead of accountability, as if customers are the problem for expecting honesty. Basic transparency clearly isn’t a priority here. The service is rude, dismissive, and unprofessional. No greeting, no patience, no care. It feels like you’re inconveniencing them by ordering food at a bagel shop. And the bagels? Easily the worst I’ve had. Dry, bland, and somehow served cold — even when ordered as a sandwich. Who serves a bagel sandwich without warming the bagel? That’s not a preference issue, that’s basic competence. On top of all that, there are serious hygiene concerns. Employees wer

Bagels are always good and fresh but any sandwich is just dry. Doesn’t matter what I get whether it’s bacon egg and cheese, sausage I’m not sure if they make the sandwiches without butter but it’s so dry and ruins the sandwich. Extra bonus points for really good chicken salad depending on who makes it. Staff is friendly although always busy and a little slow.

Wally’s Bagel Store is absolutely amazing. The sandwiches are the best I’ve ever had—fresh, delicious, and made perfectly every time. The prices are very affordable, which makes it even better. Great quality, great service, and incredible food. I will definitely keep coming back. Highly recommended! 🥯🥪✨

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Five Stars – The Best Bagel Experience, Hands Down I don’t write reviews often, but this bagel store absolutely deserves it. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with the warm, comforting smell of freshly baked bagels — and that alone tells you everything you need to know. These are not mass-produced, rubbery bagels. These are authentic, hand-rolled, perfectly boiled-and-baked bagels done the right way. The texture is flawless: golden and slightly crisp on the outside, beautifully chewy on the inside. The kind of chew that reminds you what a real bagel is supposed to taste like. The everything bagel is generously seasoned (no bare spots!), the sesame and poppy seed bagels are perfectly toasted, and even the plain bagel shines — which is the ultimate test of quality. The cr

I ordered two Turkey sandwiches for takeout at Walley’s Bagel Cafe. It took 25–30 minutes, and others who ordered after me were served first. The delay made the experience frustrating, and the food itself was just average. I won’t return until timing and pickup accuracy improve.