Umberto's of Lake Grove

Had to leave a review. Regular slice of pizza... not great. I'd give it a 5.3 out of 10. I've had worse but rarely on long island. Their Grandma Vodka pizza, however, is great. Its got to be one of the best Grandma Vodka slices I've ever had. And if I have the option I always order Grandma Vodka slices because they remind me of family gatherings at my Nana's (i miss those times). But now this is my new favorite. Either here or Marys in Islip Terrace, or if your in Nassau: Vincents in Bellmore

There is nothing like Umberto’s. They are truly the best of the best. If you ever get a chance, try the seafood risotto, it is out of this world. The staff are wonderful and really care about you and your family, the food is incredibly delicious and the atmosphere is perfection. The only downside is that I wish they had more space for private parties to fit our big Italian family!

Pizza had a great fluffy and light crispy crust with delicious sauce and a generous amount of topping. Also the people were really nice and a cozy atmosphere.

great pizza our server/counter person who was the girl with the lip and nose ring was condescending, rude and what felt like completely ignoring my family. Come to find out we were charged for things we didn’t even order and she came back saying we were still $15 short after making sure to give her the right amount of money but apparently it wasn’t there anymore! If you come please avoid female employee with lip ring and nose ring, I have come here so many times and never have i seen an employee just be so in their own world and full of narcissism .

Stopped in for a slice just because they were the closest pizza to where we were staying in Lake Grove. Now I wouldn’t go anywhere else. The pizza slices were wonderful and the staff was so friendly. You can tell from the way the restaurant is taken care of that the owners are invested in its success. My only regret is that I did not ask to see all the available slices before ordering a cheese slice. The assorted pizzas are by the front counter. Next time I’ll ask and be more adventurous in my choice.