TPR Restaurant and Bar

This is one of my family’s go to spots in Tenafly as we have been coming here for years. They have a nice variety of Italian choices on their menu, however we usually opt for the pizzas. I like that they offer different kinds of pies to fit whatever you may be in the mood for. They serve thin crust, grandma pies, gluten free pies, and my favorite the Sicilian. The Sicilian is my first choice because I am a fan of thicker heavy crusts that can hold everything together well; it is also nice and filling as I never finish up hungry which is very important. In our order, we typically get a large pepperoni pie with mushrooms, and a large Sicilian and just look at these pictures. Do I need to say anything else? Both of those pies are covered in toppings and cheese giving a great experience.

I have to say this is the worst pizza I have ever eaten, and I’ve eaten many. It’s truly inedible. We ordered delivery. I got a grandma pie with chicken cutlet, for 27 dollars… there was about 5 small pieces of chicken on it. It looked bad and when I took a bite it was like eating old stale rubbery pizza. It was definitely an old pizza they reheated! The cheese tasted like Daiya vegan cheese. The fries were dry and stale as well. I can’t believe they charge these prices and I cannot fathom why there are so many good reviews on this place. I don’t usually even write reviews but I feel I had to to save someone from spending 27 dollars on a pizza I could have gotten out of the frozen section better for 10 dollars.

I would absolutely give TPR 5 stars, and if I could give more, I would! I truly appreciate the customer service and care they put into everything they do. The management and staff are incredibly welcoming, friendly, and make you feel genuinely appreciated. When I go out to a local restaurant, I always look for a place that feels like home and TPR does exactly that. Fresh food, delicious flavors, a simple and cozy atmosphere, and kind people all around. Whether you’re stopping by for a drink and a quick snack, bringing family for an amazing dinner, or even heading out on a snowy or rainy day, nothing beats enjoying something fresh and comforting from their menu. Highly recommend TPR—a true local gem!

TPR is an amazing local Italian restaurant with many options. I’ve eaten here weekly since the new owner took over. It’s been redecorated and the owner is culinarily trained so no joke. I would give ten stars if I could! Come enjoy and be as beyond satisfied as I am. Enjoy!!!!

I just happened to order here on Grubhub and was delivered the most phenomenal eggplant parm hero I’ve ever had. Bread toasted to perfection, crunchy and delicious with the right amount of cheese, sauce and eggplant. It wasn’t cheap but it was worth every penny. I wish this spot was local for me as I just happened to be in the area but I might do something crazy and drive 25 minutes just to try it again.