Tony’s of NY

Tony’s is a little slice of Italy in Mays Chapel. You will just love the New York décor – names of New York Subway stops on the wall as well as vintage pictures. There are separate ordering and dining areas. You ordered at the counter, and they bring your food to you. The menu is quite extensive covering everything from Appetizers, Pizza Man Specialties, Chicken Wings, Soups, Sides, Fresh Salads, Cheesesteaks, Classic Subs, Old Time Favorites (think pastas), 21 different pizzas, and desserts. They offer Lunch Combo Deals starting at $7.99. You will definitely find something here you like. There are booths that seat 2 or 4, counter seating, and tables for 4. They do not take reservations. They do a brisk carry-out business. We met friends for dinner on a Saturday evening. First, we lik

My first time trying this restaurant and I thought that the pizza was really delicious but a tad bit pricey in my opinion. 16 inch pizza, a large fry and three drinks came to about $40. But the pizza was really good and wasn’t really greasy/oily like most places. I’ve been back since for carryout (spent about $25) and the pizza taste just as good at home than it did eating it directly at the pizzeria. The restaurant itself is kind of small, so really large groups may have a tough time getting situated. Restrooms were clean and the staff was really nice. Definitely would recommend and I will be returning for takeout. Follow more reviews @IG: Robthefoodguy @eat_n_critique

My husband and I order from Tony's often and love it. Recently, we tried out their catering for a holiday family gathering of 25. Everything was wonderful (four types of pizza, two pasta dishes, two salad trays, and cannolis (of course)). When the food arrived - right on time - it presented wonderfully and was hot! Our guests enjoyed! Thank you Tony's Team!

What a great place for some delicious Italian food. First time here and will return. Met Tony and enjoyed talking with him.

Well this pizza is delicious! Staff are super friendly and helpful! We are not from the area but happy we stumbled upon this gem and will always be back when we are there. The godfather pizza was amazing and exactly how it should be!!! They will not disappoint.