Tommy's Pizza Palace

I visited Tommy’s Pizza Palace with some friends and had a nice experience! The owner was very friendly and attentive, and the pizza and dishes we shared were good. I don’t often have Greek pizza, so it was a nice change, and I felt they did it well! I love the classic pizza parlor vibes and how unchanged it seemed to be. Special shout-out on the cold cut grinder, which was really tasty!

It was the first time I had visited this restaurant in decades. When I was a child my family ordered from them often. I ordered two grinders: one meatball and one sausage. Unfortunately, I was disappointed by the meat in both sandwiches. The meatball did not resemble any I had seen before—it came in large slices similar to meatloaf, yet lacked any real meat texture and flavor. The sausage, while shaped correctly, also failed to taste and chew like sausage. Despite my dissatisfaction with the meats, I found the bread, cheese, mushrooms, onions, and peppers to be good.

I ordered up a pickup order through Slice. I ordered a medium buffalo chicken pizza for a total of almost $30, which is a pretty steep price for a 14 inch pizza even when compared to the overpriced places on Main Street in Middletown. The description for my pizza on Slice said it included blue cheese (photograph of menu included.) When I went to pick up the pizza, I was met by an annoyed sounding working rolling her eyes telling me “we will be with you in a minute”. Being stressed/rushed is understandable, but the place was empty so I’m not sure what the attitude was related to. Maybe they had a lot of takeout orders for dinner rush, not sure. After waiting a bit in the (empty) restaurant, my pizza was handed to me. At which time they tried to tell me blue cheese wasn’t included and wanted

One of the best pizzas we’ve ever had!! Staff was awesome, fixings were fresh and sauce on pizza was wonderful! We split a medium Tommy special pizza and we’re bursting at the seams!

Fantastic pizza and even more fantastic staff! Can't recommend highly enough!!!