The Windmill Belgian Waffles & Ice Cream

We went on a very busy night and the staff was working hard. We got two ice cream cones: 1 sherbert and 1 choco taco ice cream flavor! Both were very good. I have been here in the past and loved their belgian waffle ice cream sundaes as well

This is a well established, high end ice cream shop nestled in the middle of quaint little shops. Parking was a snap. The service was friendly and the ice cream was top notch. I would definitely recommend this as one of your stops. When you stop, ask if Felicity is there. She is the owner and she will make sure your experience is a good one.

The Windmill on LBI is THE place to get ice cream! Located in Bay Village, this shop is full of friendly faces and delicious ice cream flavors. During our frequent trips to the shop, we enjoyed vanilla, cookies n’ cream, sweet and salty, rocky road, strawberry, black raspberry, and cookie dough. It’s almost impossible to pick a favorite but I would have to go with the waffle topped with a scoop of each strawberry and black raspberry ice cream, fresh strawberries, and whipped cream. Ah-maze-ing!!! Can’t wait to try more flavors next time I’m in LBI!

The ice cream is decent BUT the service is really bad. We bought ice cream for our 3 kids ($20ish dollars). My daughter ordered the cookie ice cream and it came bright blue with not a single cookie chunk. Didn’t taste great. If it was even decent, she would have ate it (she literally eats everything!), but it was really not good. When I so politely told them she didn’t like it (hoping either we could get a new kind or a discount on a new one), the staff was so rude! Immediately telling me it was my fault because I didn’t ask for a sample. The manager came out and said “do you want to purchase a new one or not?” I ended up paying for a full replacement - which honestly would have been ok from the beginning if their response was kind instead of defensive and accusatory. I have never had tre

Ice cream itself was good. However the lady that took my order had been complaining to customers about scooping icecream. She was blatantly rude. I walked away to give my brother his icecream and she started complaining to customers that “she walked away just like they always do” I work at a icecream place and if we were to ever speak like this to customers we would get introuble