The Pie Safe

As we stepped into the Pie Safe, there was a beautiful lady behind the counter slicing pies. My husband made a joke, “I’m just messing with you!” It was the owner and she came out from behind the counter with so much charm! She jokingly said, “Don’t make me get my spatula!” I giggled. She asked how she could help us, and I begged for a slice of her delicious blueberry pie. Let me tell you, I’m from Alabama and I have never seen a pie look so good. I also had an iced latte, and my husband got a warm one. Both were so yummy. This shop is truly like stepping back in time. It’s a familiar sense of comfort, as well as the pie. And if you get the chance, you have to meet the owner. You can tell she made the place what it is!

Family members said this was the best pie ever! They were absolutely right! You walk in, and it smells divine. There is worship music playing. There are scriptures on the wall. The pies looked so incredible it was so hard to choose what we wanted. One thing they could work on, is speed. I guess it probably was taking so long because the gal taking orders was making drinks? That doesn’t seem like the best system…… I also didn’t think the girl working was the most friendly girl I’ve talked to since we’ve been in Branson. They could take some lessons from the girls at sonic. Those are the friendliest people I’ve ever met!! Other than waiting, and an awkward interaction at the counter, the pie was absolutely so amazing we will go back tomorrow to get another before we leave back to head home

The Triple Chocolate and Peanut Butter Cream Pies at The Pie Safe are top-notch. Rich chocolate, smooth peanut butter cream—every bite hits just right.

This small pie shop is incredibly cute and delicious. I got the mini Dutch apple pie and the filling was probably the best I've ever had. It was very flavorful and had lots of yummy seasonings along with crumbles on top. We also got the Spring Berry pie which had apples, strawberries, and raspberries in it! They also have inside and outside seating for when it is nice! Very pretty interior.

I tried an apple pie and a pecan pie. Both were good, but would have been better heated up. The person working the counter was nice and friendly. The atmosphere was alright, just not my thing. However, it was as other reviewers have described. The 4 stars is because I wasn’t super impressed with the pie itself. Like I said, it would have been better warm.