The Milleridge Inn

The Milleridge Inn feels like stepping into a charming historic home warm, beautifully decorated, and full of character. The food has that true house‑made taste, the kind that feels comforting from the first bite. Portions are big, so come hungry. I had the roast pot and the chicken lemon piccata, and both were flavorful, tender, and clearly made with care. And the bread… they give you so much of it, fresh and perfect for soaking up every sauce. The décor is another highlight cozy, detailed, and full of that homey, nostalgic vibe that makes you want to linger. It’s the kind of place where you instantly feel relaxed and taken care of. I loved the atmosphere and would definitely come back.

This was my first time at the Milleridge Inn for dinning. It's Christmas time so it was extremely busy. Be prepared for a bit of confusion if you go btwn 12pm and 1pm. The hostess was great to keep things moving. Once you arrive you're in for a treat with the decorations alone. The food adds to the whole experience. The servers were polite, knowledgeable and quick. They had Dickes Carolers which puts the icing on the cake. I see why this is the most popular spot during Christmas on LI. I'll be back.

The atmosphere is charming and full of character, the kind of place that makes you feel warm and welcomed the moment you walk in. The food was outstanding: fresh, flavorful, and beautifully served. The staff was incredibly kind and attentive, making sure everything was perfect throughout the meal. From start to finish, the service and ambiance were exceptional. A truly memorable dining experience. Highly recommended!

Visited The Milleridge Inn for a Halloween event, and it was a fantastic experience! The party atmosphere was lively, with awesome live music and plenty of dancing. The full-course meal was delicious and well-prepared, making the night even better. The crowd was friendly, and the costumes added a fun, festive vibe to the event. Overall, a great place for a themed night out with good food, music, and company.

Been going here since a child with my parents, over 50 years, I guess. You go there for the atmosphere and surroundings, especially at the holidays, and it's very beautiful and nostalgic. The food used to be much better than it's been the past few years. For the price, the food and service are not that good, just adequate. But, as I said, the main attraction is just being there.