The Hungry Captain - Best Maine Lobster Rolls in Cape Coral

This little hidden gem is tucked away around a few corners but delightfully turned out to be well worth the search! Right from the start the establishment was well lit, incredibly clean and the staff was fantastically friendly. You can see by the picture attached the lobster meat to roll ratio was incredibly generous, and well I spent about 35 bucks I left absolutely full and happy so definitely worth the price. There's more than a few lobster roll places in town lately, given their choices on how to get your role I'm giving this place extra points for creativity and options. Do self a favor and stop in sometime, the friendly faces will make sure you get fed right!

The staff was very pleasant and kind. The lobster roll was amazing and hit the spot for sure! The pickles are nice and dilly and tangy not those half sour ones. Very clean and cute atmosphere and for the price very well constructed. I assume the owner, had given me a pineapple juice on the house because it was empty when I’d ordered. Very kind 🙂‍↕️😄. Will be returning and sending friends and family to try!

“Fantastic” Lobster rolls!! The lobster bisque was also very good. Hard to find place but a must try. Staff is super helpful and friendly.. will be back many times for sure!!

I just happen to be driving in the area and spotted this gem. I pulled up a little after 7pm and was unaware they closed at 7pm. As I walked up to the store and realized they were closed, I started to make my way back to my car, as I go to get in my car the staff comes out and tells me they are closed but are willing to make me a lobster roll to go.The Lobster roll was amazing, but better than that was the attentive service and the willingness to go above and beyond for the customer and for that you just earned a customer for life!! Keep up the great work. Came to the captain hungry, left with a full belly!! 🤌🤌

The Hungry Captain Cape Coral 9-19-25 We just got back from Maine and had to stop by for some Lobster Rolls. When we walked in this place was very clean and neat as a pin. They had 2 kiosk or a large counter you can order from. Menu was laid out well and Mairelis who was working behind the counter could not have been any more friendly and helpful to us as it was our first time there. We both ordered the New England Maine Lobster Roll Combo. This Cold Lobster Roll came with Lobster on a Toasted Bun, Mayo, Chips, Pickle Spear and Slice of Lemon. I also ordered a bowl of Clam Chowder Soup. Our order was delivered to our table in reasonable time, it looked so appetizing. The Bun was overflowing of Lobster, and it was toasted to a golden brown just the way I like it. The Clam Chowder was amazi