The Cookie Jar

The staff is always so sweet, and the cookies are not only delicious but also adorable! I pre-ordered the houses and apples, and they turned out perfect. For the Christmas cookies, I was able to just walk in and grab them off the shelf—so convenient! I love handing these out to clients, family, and friends. You can’t go wrong with a thoughtful, sweet treat!

My real estate team ordered a batch of custom cookies from The Cookie Jar in Freeport, and they were absolutely perfect! Not only did they look incredible, but they tasted just as amazing. The attention to detail, from the design to the flavor, truly exceeded my expectations. The team was so friendly and accommodating, making the entire process seamless. Whether you need custom treats for a special occasion or just want a delicious cookie, this is the place to go. Highly recommend!

Oh my goodness, I had the most amazing latte at the Cookie Jar last week. It was made with such care with such fresh coffee beans. We all know the cookies are best in class but man, that coffee is to die for. I can’t wait to go back!

Loft house who???? These cookies i got during the mistletoe walk today. The fluffy, light. The frosting was smooth, with that classic crust that forms on them giving them the perfect texture. 👌 amazing you've got a new life long customer! Can't wait to get more!

Definitely one of the best places to get some amazing cookies!!! The staff was so friendly, accommodating and helpful as they let me send in a last minute 4 dozen cookie order before the 4th of July and their break/time off (for a birthday party on the 7th). The cookies stayed fresh and tasted phenomenal even 4 days after I got them! I felt like a jerk ordering so many cookies last minute and they didn’t seem to mind at all and were more than happy to help! Thank you guys so much!!! If you haven’t tried them already the sour cream cookies are to die for! 20/10 recommend!!!!