The BlackSheep at Miller Place

The BlackSheep is our go to since they opened their doors! Whether you are dining in or order out the food is delicious! Even when I doordash the food arrives hot every time. We had my 40th birthday party here and everything was perfectly executed! All of my guests raved about the food and loved it as much as I do! John and his staff are a great team and always bring great vibes! We are there so much they truly have become our friends! They provide amazing service and incredible food every time! I highly recommend you go see them and grab a bite to eat ASAP!

Lets talk about it!! This place was a FIND!!! You know when they say we have Mack and cheese and then ask you what you want on top of it its about to go down. I chose the candied bacon (which also had crisp fried onions and green oninon) Delish!! I had the Between the Herd Sandwich, it didnt miss. This place was great. Family owned and friendly, bread baked locally (supporting their community) and they have gluten free alternatives. Run and get a taste of Delish!! Also try out their Tiramisu. Yum!!

Have a lot to say about this place, and it’s proprietor, Jonathan. We had last minute booked our daughter’s 2nd birthday here, after seeing some good reviews online. Jonathan IS an outstanding host, an exceptional cook, and one of the most generous business owners I have ever had the pleasure of working with. His number one concern was that we had a good time with our friends and family. I’m happy to say we had exactly that and more. Good customer service is more than enough to get me back into your doors. Not only does The Black Sheep go out of their way to cater to their clientele, the food was out of this world delicious. Food presentation was colorful and beautiful (yes, even the orchids are edible😂) The location is quaint, and very family oriented. I would encourage anyone and everyon

We just had our daughter’s second birthday party here, oh my god! I could not have found a better place with a better owner to have her party. The entire party went off without a hitch and everything including the food came out amazing! Jonathan the owner was checking on us the entire time making sure all was good and couldn’t have been a better host if he tried! Thank you so much for all the amazing food and the beautiful atmosphere! We loved every second of it and will be having our future events here. Love love love everything about this place!!!!

We had tried the pretzel with a great cheese sauce, The squeaking sammie, chopped cheese, Mac and cheese and their chocolate flourless cake. Everything we had was delicious. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, the staff was great, the food came out quick and again was amazing. We cannot wait to go back!