McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor

Been a while since we've been here. The staff (as always) are great. We were dissapointed the first few flavors we selected were not available and they were out of peanut butter topping. The chocolate shake was meh, it was watery, not thick and definitely not as flavorful as we remembered. The black raspberry truffle ice cream was the star of the show, it was delish! Sadly we won't be back.

More than just delicious homemade ice cream! Organized, flexible, and very willing to make sure your party has all you want and need to be a hit!

I’m a big ice cram guy and my girlfriend mentioned this place since it’s close to her house. we have gone three times and ALL 3 times have been completely dysfunctional. all 3 times the milkshake machine was turned off when they were still open (45-50 minutes before closing). all 3 times the employees were visibly annoyed that we were there way before closing and all 3 times I was not able to get what I wanted. The hours online should probably be updated and I will not be returning.

Not your typical ice cream shop! Enjoy McNulty’s delicious ice cream presented in a fun and creative way. Something for everyone, including frozen yogurt and dairy free ice cream. Staff is welcoming and helpful. This shop is a must try!!!!!

McNulty is a great family place for ice cream. Located on the eastern north shore or long island, it has a calm atmosphere, quaint outside seating and offers a good selection of ice creams, toppings, and other treats. It's been in operation since 1992 and seems to continue to do well. It's settled amongst neighborhoods and likely has a decent local following from the nearby homes and small businesses.